The girl or the tiger? Men and women have been thinking about this concern since 1882, whenever Frank Stockton published it in Century mag. It’s an interesting psychological dilemma that actually comes down seriously to a very important factor: Which overpowers one other, love or envy? Can love really go as far as to cause somebody agony just to save a life? Can jealousy really go in terms of to inflict murder? Evidence given into the brief tale highly implies that jealousy can and does overwhelm love—that is, your tiger had been behind the proper door.
The quick tale The Lady or the Tiger? by Frank Stockton poses an interesting mental dilemma. The essential premise of the tale is a king who attempts all the topics that are accused of crimes exactly the same way: they truly are let into an arena with two doorways. Behind one home is a ferocious tiger that’ll rip them to shreds immediately. Behind one other home is an attractive dude whom they’ll be wed to within seconds, regardless of any past wives. The accused must pick a door, and whatever is behind the doorway they pick—be it tiger or maiden—decides their fate.
The king’s daughter was indeed having an affair with a commoner for all months. Whenever the king found out, he was furious and sentenced the young man to choose a door. The princess, terrified throughout the fate of her love, learned which home the tiger was behind and which door the girl had been at the rear of.
Furthermore, she additionally discovered who the girl behind the doorway was—a damsel of court, whom the woman enthusiast had talked to before on many occasions. The princess was filled up with overwhelming angst and jealousy and spent numerous evenings throwing and switching over how to proceed.
Finally, your day the girl lover’s fate was to be determined arrived, in which he stepped out to the arena. He spun around and looked at the princess. She pointed to the right door. No-one saw for everyone’s eyes were fixed upon the young man. Without a doubt, he pivoted and pointed toward the right home. Which, my friends, is in which the story stops. It kept up to your reader to evaluate the princess and her motives and decide which she would point the woman fan to—the woman who she despised and could maybe not keep seeing him hitched to, or the tiger which would leave him a bloody, soupy mess.
In the event that lady did indeed leave the door, why did the princess tell the girl fan to decide on that one? She said by herself that if the woman enthusiast had been wed to some other, it will be like having her “soul burned in agony.” She already thought that the woman fan as well as the lady of this court might have had a secret relationship on the side of hers, and she could not bear to see that come into actuality. Alternatively, she may have believed that when they could never be together in life, they could be together in death.
Due to the fact princess speculates, “wouldn’t it be better for him to die at the same time, and visit wait for the girl inside blessed regions of semi-barbaric futurity?” If she thinks in the afterlife, she could let him perish, and destroy by herself afterwards, and they could live joyfully ever after in paradise, with no reference to that pesky lady associated with the court.
The princess additionally might have opted for the tiger because she hated the girl her enthusiast might marry. Because of the hate twisting inside her, she may have wished the girl the maximum amount of harm possible. If killing her lover caused the girl damage, then, therefore, be it—she was therefore barbaric, there was no end to the woman wrath when it stumbled on things she really and deeply hated. The princess desired the woman to have the exact same discomfort that she would have in the event that two had been wed.
The princess could have additionally delivered the tiger out to ensure that she wouldn’t have experienced to cope with the lady and her lover being hitched. If she pointed him towards the doorway with all the woman behind it, then she’d need certainly to see them hitched. She would see them around town together and most likely fulfill their children, and live with all the fact that she cannot be along with her fan each day until she passed away. If she picked the doorway utilizing the tiger behind it, but he’d perish immediately. She would be sad, yes, but she might get over it more quickly. She didn’t understand two together, and she’d find a new love eventually.
Refutation and Concession
Having said that, assume the princess’ love had been strong sufficient that she cannot keep to see him die. Once the story states, “how frequently, in her waking hours as well as in her goals, had she started in crazy horror, and covered her face with her arms as she thought of her lover starting the door on the other hand of which waited the cruel fangs of tiger!” Perhaps, ultimately, she’d instead see him alive than dead, no matter if it implied he was paired with some other girl. Maybe if she certainly liked him, she would do everything in her capacity to make him since delighted as you are able to, no matter if that resulted in her very own misery.
However, the princess generally seems to act chiefly inside her very own self-interest. In beginning the event, she showed complete disregard for societal norms and for how her actions would reflect upon the royal lineage. She allows her emotions to outweigh the logical pattern she must have followed, so what is to say that she won’t let that take place once more? In the first situation, her love overcame class separation. In this situation, wouldn’t the girl envy have actually overcome the logical solution of having her enthusiast live so that they could carry on the key love affair? Yes, the girl behind the door could be the practical, logos-driven choice. But oftentimes emotion overcomes logic, plus in this instance, the princess ended up being most likely swept away by the woman’s jealousy. She’d do anything to stop her fan from marrying another woman.
Therefore within land for the semi-barbaric king, of simple choices that cause either life or death, just what happened toward lover—life or death? His life was at stake, yet he vested absolute certainty in the princess. He trusted the lady to choose what was best for him, and she picked death. She did it for herself, mostly, making sure that she would not need to see him with another woman, therefore that woman could be denied the love your princess had been also. She made it happen for him, to make certain that whenever she passed away, they are often together within the afterlife. The tiger came out so the princess could get just what she desired so that in the end, her envy overcame the woman’s love.
The End! Hope you enjoyed it!
Of the Writer and the Story
The story “The Lady or the Tiger?” is from Frank R. Stockton, a 19th c. American writer. It is meant for children but its end is for mature audience, especially for those who are good at understanding women’s heart. It is about a semi-barbaric king. His ideas are polished –“Good should be rewarded and Evil should be punished.” But his way of justice to the accused is barbaric -with a tiger to tear or a lady to reward.
The Vast Arena as the Trial Place
The king had a built a vast arena that served to entertain the public and to administer justice. The accused would be brought to this amphitheatre for trial. He would have two choices. If he opened one door, a ferocious hungry tiger would jump upon him and tear him into pieces for his crime. If he opened the other door, a beautiful lady would come out and marry him for his innocence. The King’s judgement looks fair because it arises from impartial and incorruptible chance.
King’s Daughter and her Lover on Trial
The king had a daughter who loved a young handsome courtier. He came to know the love affair and put the lover on Trial. King’s daughter bribed and found the secret -which door carried the Tiger and which one, the most beautiful lady. But she was in a dilemma. Whatever the door is opened, she would be the loser. Moreover, she was hateful and jealous of the lady in cage. On the appointed day, the lover looked for a signal from his sweetheart. King’s daughter showed the right door secretly and the lover opened it.
The Mysterious End
It is an open-ended story and the writer did not tell who came out -the Lady or the Tiger? We do not know what happened to the handsome young man. Life is mysterious and we do not know what will happen next. So is the end of the Story. The writer asks us to be in the heart of the hot-blooded, semi-barbaric princess and then find the answer. Which is powerful – her love, or her jealousy, or her semibarbarism? Who is clever – the king, or the princess, or the Writer, or the reader? Everything is open secret.
Questions and Answers:
- Describe the semi-barbaric king.
The king’s ideas are polished –“Good should be rewarded and Evil should be punished.” But his way of justice to the accused is barbaric -with a tiger to tear or, a lady to reward. He uses his power to turn his fancies into facts.
- How did he refine and culture the minds of his subjects? (Or) What was the choice given to the person on Trial? (Or) What happened if he opens the door having a lady behind?
The accused would have two choices. If he opened one door, a ferocious hungry tiger would jump upon him and tear him into pieces for his crime. If he opened the other door, a beautiful lady would come out and marry him for his innocence.
- Comment on the perfect fairness of the king’s method of administering justice.
It is really not “perfect fairness” though it looks so. If his method is perfect, how was the princess able to find the secret by bribing? If he is really fair in justice, why doesn’t he put the princess in the other door in stead of another lady?
- What happened when the king discovered his daughter’s love affair? (Or) How did the audience react to the sight of the young man?
The king came to know the love affair and put the lover on Trial. People assembled in great number and were much interested to know what would happen. They had never seen such a trial before.
- Describe the plight of the princess.
The princess was in a dilemma. Whatever the door is opened, she would be the loser. Her lover would be killed or marry another lady. Moreover, she was hateful and jealous of the lady in cage.
- How did the young man know which door to choose?
On the appointed day, the lover looked for a signal from his sweetheart. King’s daughter showed the right door secretly and the lover opened it.
- What happened to the handsome young man at the end?
The writer did not tell who came out -the Lady or the Tiger. He asks us to be in the heart of the hot-blooded, semi-barbaric princess and then find the answer. So the tiger might have killed the young man.
Passionate love and jealousy can make people do things that might seem unthinkable. The story of Frank Stockton, “The Lady or the Tiger?” is about the love between two young people, a princess and a young man, which is considered a crime. Everything starts with the disclosure of the affairs between these two people by a barbaric-king, who then with the purpose of disposing of the youth, sends him to a specially created trial, to administer his so-called “Poetic Justice”. Ultimately, the fate of the youth, whether to die or to be awarded a beautiful lady, lies in the hands of the princess.
The author of the story left the readers to decide whether there is a tiger or a lady behind the chosen door and prompts the audience to choose one of these alternatives. However, if one thinks carefully, there might have been a third alternative, and in my opinion, the optimal and fairest one: behind both doors lie a dead tiger and a dead lady (this is of course being done by the princess).
The idea behind this alternative is that if the doors revealed dead bodies, assuming that in their religion then believed in supernatural powers, this might have provided good justification to the king and people, that this particular youth is the chosen one. Seeing this, I think that the king would have allowed his daughter to marry the youth.
There are several reasons why I believe that the doors contained a dead tiger and a dead lady. Reading the story we find out that love between these two was strong, which is depicted by the following quotation: “She loved him with an ardour that had enough of barbarism in it to make it exceedingly warm and strong”(p.195).
We also see that “love affair moved on happily for months”(p.195), and with this description of their passionate love we can say with certainty that there is a lot of probability that the princess would do anything to make her lover stay alive.
If you had the choice for your lover to either marry another woman whom you despise or be eaten alive by a tiger what would you choose? The short story “The Lady or The Tiger” is about a semi-barbaric king whose idea of justice is either death by a tiger if you find yourself guilty of marriage whether you like it or not if you find yourself guilty. The king discovers an affair between his daughter, the princess, and one of his men.
He puts the young man on trial in a place called the King’s Arena. No one, including the princess, is supposed to know which door the lady and the tiger lie behind, but the princess discovers which door is which and has to decide where to lead her lover. “It should be clear that Stockton provides enough evidence of the princess choosing the tiger for her lover. ”
The princess chose the door with the tiger because no one else should be worthy of the young man’s love. The young man was so handsome that no one but the princess deserved his love and affection. “Tall, beautiful, fair, his appearance was greeted with a low hum of admiration and anxiety. Half the audience had not known so grand a youth lived among them” (Stockton 2). The princess didn’t believe anyone else was worthy of a lover as beautiful as him and that only she should have him. The young man’s appearance is more suited to the life of high nobility and that is why no one expected that such a handsome man lived among them.
The princess despises the maiden chosen for her lover in the event that he chooses the door that proves him innocent. The princess hated the lady chosen for her lover as a reward, so she would not want them to be together no matter what the cost was. “It was one of the fairest and loveliest of the damsels of the court who had been selected as the reward of the accused youth, should he be proved innocent of the crime of aspiring to one so far above him and the princess hated her” (Stockton 3).
The princess feels that everyone else is unworthy of the young man’s love and that only she is good enough to have him. The princess hates the maiden that would be married to her love if he chooses that door because the princess doesn’t like her, she would not want the maiden to be happy with her lover or her lover to be happy with the maiden.
The princess chose the door with the tiger behind it. Stockton wanted us to see this as fact. The princess chose to direct her lover to the door of the tiger because she didn’t believe anyone deserved his love. He was so handsome, and his features were fitted to the noble class. She also chose this door because she hated the maiden chosen for her lover and didn’t want to think of the thought of them being happy together. The semi-barbaric princess chose the door with the tiger that leads her lover to certain death because she couldn’t bear to see him with another woman.
Standing in the center of a larger arena was a young youth whose faith was in the balances. Spectators raise steely on all sides directly in front of him awaiting his death. In front of him were two massive doors behind one were life and bliss, behind another lies a man-eating beast.
The choice he makes of the two doors solely depending on a Semi-Barbaric princess. Whose train of thought might be different from that of a person who is sound of mind. Being of her background, she would easily have led the youth to the door of the beast. Her choice would reflect these three reasons her jealousy, upbringing and her pride.
Jealousy can consume a person and alter their frame of mind.
His fervent and imperious ways were instilled in her since birth. Knowing the princess’s nature, the king did not just “happen” to find out about their affair it was planned. The fact was obvious, her choice in men was not one of which her father would approve.
The discovery was a perfect way to rid her of the youth. She had no future.
This passage has even implied that she took pleasure in attending and was so terribly interested. Her interest was not to see her lover with another woman but to see him being ripe apart by the savage relentless beast.
Lastly, her pride would have been hurt. Being royalty, a princess would have standards and responsibilities to uphold. A king’s daughter should not associate with peasants. Lead alone has an affair with one. What better way than to send him to his death, By doing this she would gain the respect back from her father back and the kingdom would soon forget her behaviour.
Conclusion with these three reason her jealousy, pride and your upbringing this story would have had an alternate ending. While the young man was reaching his hand to open the right door, he changed his mind. As his heart was tightened with the strong love of the princess, he thought that dying by the tiger would rather be better than betray his lover. So, he went right to the left door and opened it. A few minutes after, a beautiful, lovely lady came out.
The story The Lady, or the Tiger reveals foreshadowing in the beginning when the king’s arena is introduced stating that, “When a subject was accused of a crime of sufficient importance to interest the king, public notice was given that on an appointed day the fate of the accused person would be decided in the king’s arena.”
This is foreshadowing the event where the princess dates a servant, and he’s thrown into the arena. Since the incident was such a surprise to the king and it angered him so much that a man would have the audacity to date his daughter that he let fate decide what would happen to boy.
My reaction to the end of the book was anger because at the end of the story I was met with this; “And so I leave it with all of you: Which came out of the opened door,–the lady, or the tiger?” I wanted to actually know, not have to assume what happened. The feeling of never know what actually happened made me furious. It was worse than a cliffhanger because when a cliffhanger happens, there is a possibility that the ending will be answered in another movie or book, but not for The Lady, or the Tiger?, you’re forced to just assume what will happen to the boy and there’s no way that it’ll ever be answered, by the man who wrote the short story.
The people of the town support this method because it was source of entertainment On page 14 it was stated that, “When the people gathered together on one of the great trial days, they never knew whether they were to witness a bloody slaughter or a hilarious wedding.” Since this was so entertaining it was supported by the people that lived in the town.
The boy’s struggle in the story was external because he’s being hunted by the king for dating his daughter. The struggle is an external conflict because it’s the boy vs the king. As stated in The Lady, or the Tiger?, “The youth was immediately cast into prison, and a day was appointed for his trial in the king’s arena.” There was nothing the boy could do to escape from the king’s wrath.
The princess’s internal conflict played a huge roll in The Lady, or the Tiger?, because it was the conflict of the story. On page 18 the story reads, “How often, in her waking hours and in her dreams, had she started in wild horror, and covered her face with her hands as she thought of her lover opening the door on the other side of which waited for the cruel fangs of the tiger! But how much oftener had she seen him at the other door!
How in her grievous reveries had she gnashed her teeth, and torn her hair, when she saw his start of rapturous delight as he opened the door of the lady! How her soul had burned in agony when she had seen him rush to meet that woman.” Without this internal struggle, the story wouldn’t be as interesting because, if the princess didn’t hate the woman then she would’ve saved the boy she loved.
Cite this page
This content was submitted by our community members and reviewed by Essayscollector Team. All content on this page is verified and owned by Essayscollector Team. All comments and user reviews are moderated by Essayscollector Team. In the case of any content-related problem, you can reach us through the report button.