Searching for an essay?

Browse the database of more than 3800 essays donated by our community members!

Is Knowledge Justified True Belief?

The knowledge being talked about in the question is propositional knowledge. An example of propositional knowledge is; “my name is Bert” justified true belief, which is a proposition that someone feels is correct and for which they have a cogent argument for believing so and which is in fact true. But is knowledge equivalent to justified true belief? For knowledge to be equivalent to justified true belief, it follows that justified true belief is necessary and sufficient for knowledge. Belief is necessary for knowledge since without belief you would be unable to maintain that you knew a certain proposition. For example, you may say that you know that you are holding a pen in your hand but unless you believed you were holding a pen in your hand you couldn’t know that.

Some level of justification is also necessary for knowledge since to feel that you know something you must have some cogent argument to allow yourself to believe it. For example “I can see water hitting the window, so it must be raining”. Truth is also necessary for knowledge since if something is not true it follows that it cannot be held to be knowledge. For example, a psychic who predicts that a card picked from a pack will be a six of hearts, even though he has got the card right for the last 100 times cannot be said to know the card will be a six of hearts until it is picked from the pack. So all three are necessary for knowledge an example would be “I know it is raining since water is falling from the clouds above my head”.

Writing service

Conditions

Website

essaypro

[Rated 4.9]

Prices start at $12
Min. deadline 6 hours
Writers: ESL
Refund: Yes


Payment methods: VISA, MasterCard, American Express

extraessay

[Rated 4.8]

Prices start at $11
Min. deadline 3 hours
Writers: ESL, ENL
Refund: Yes


Payment methods: VISA, MasterCard, American Express, Discover

extraessay

[Rated 4.75]

Prices start at $10
Min. deadline 3 hours
Writers: ESL, ENL
Refund: Yes


Payment methods: VISA, MasterCard, JCB, Discover

The only question left is; are these three criteria sufficient? It would seem that they are, however, it is possible to think of situations where a true belief can be based on a falsehood. These cases are known as Gettier cases an example is as follows; imagine a man is sleeping under a tree that has leaves thick enough to stop any rain from falling on him. Now while this man is asleep someone throws a bucket of water over him before it proceeds to rain. When the man awakes he finds himself wet and so believes that it has rained. It is true that it had rained and the man had a justification for believing so but he had no knowledge of it raining since his belief was based on a falsehood.

So it would seem that a fourth condition is necessary for knowledge. Reliabalists believe that only beliefs that are justified by a reliable method can constitute knowledge. The problem with this is that ‘reliable’ is a very vague term, for example, a reliable car may break down once a year however if an aeroplane broke down once a year it would be unreliable. They also maintain that beliefs that are based on false beliefs are not formed by a reliable method. However, there can be reliable methods for gaining true beliefs that are based on falsehoods for example the Aztecs believed that if they sacrificed people to their gods the sun would come up again the next day and when they did so the sun did indeed come up.

Cite this page

Choose cite format:
Is Knowledge Justified True Belief?. (2021, Apr 13). Retrieved May 9, 2021, from https://essayscollector.com/essays/is-knowledge-justified-true-belief/